Saxophone wizard James Carter lives up to his reputation
By Dan Emerson
Saint Paul Pioneer Press
December 10, 2008
These are bleak days for Detroit, with the Big Three automakers trying to stave off bankruptcy, and soaring numbers of unemployed workers and mortgage foreclosures.
But Tuesday night at the Dakota jazz club, saxophone wizard James Carter and his quartet — each of whom are products of Motown’s modern-jazz scene — proved the city still has grounds for civic pride.
Carter, who turns 40 in a few weeks, is considered the finest saxophonist of his generation; he lived up to the hype in his latest local appearance. With Carter on soprano sax, the combo kicked off the evening with a typically raucous composition by the late, great sax iconoclast Roland Kirk.
While drummer Leonard King and upright bassist Ralph Armstrong laid down a pulsating groove, the energetic Carter used plenty of body English to play his horn, bending from the waist and rocking back and forth, and shaking from side to side. In the spirit of the season, Carter slipped a few bars of the Christmas-season standard “Sleigh Ride.”
One of Carter’s longtime sidemen, pianist Gerard Gibbs, used a percussive keyboard attack on his solo that was in the spirit of the Kirk piece. Gibbs slyly added to the holiday mood with a few bars of “The Little Drummer Boy” in the middle of his solo ride.
Corey Wilkes, a 20-something rising-star trumpeter from Chicago, was a featured guest with the Carter Quartet. On the second tune of the set, “Mr. Dolphy” (Carter’s tribute to sax great Eric Dolphy), Wilkes blew several beboppish solo choruses over Armstrong’s throbbing bass line. On his own solo, Armstrong used a bow to make his bass-strings sing sweetly. Carter took out his bass clarinet for the next piece, an adaptation of a 1930s tune by the great saxophonist/clarinetist Sidney Bechet. The piece began with a furious, stop-time introduction, before Carter launched into a ballad, which he played beautifully — in spite of a few squeaks caused by an uncooperative sax reed.
Along the way, Carter did some resounding, polyphonic blowing in the clarinet’s lower register, almost seeming to speak through his horn.
Earlier in his career, Carter was sometimes unfairly lumped in with a group of young, neo-traditionalist jazzmen who were criticized for being more focused on the jazz classics of the past than future possibilities. But his no-holds-barred performance in Minneapolis on Tuesday showed that he has the irreverence, innovative spirit and technical skill to take old standards and totally reshape them with a modernistic twist.
One example was the combo’s exhilarating, up-tempo version of “Song of Delilah,” a song popularized by the late trumpeter Clifford Brown.
Another original from Carter’s most recent CD gave the rhythm section a chance to shine: the Latin-tinged groove “Bossa J.C.”
Late in the set, Carter left the stage, allowing Wilkes to take the spotlight with a rendition of the ballad standard “You Go To My Head,” soulfully played on flugelhorn.
Carter and his quartet will perform again tonight at the Dakota at 7 and 9:30.
Dan Emerson is a freelance writer and musician in Minneapolis.

The Irrepressible James Carter:
Pairing wine and food: A contest
The Dakota is named “Best Business Lunch” in Minnesota Monthly’s “Best of the Cities” October issue